Flat Classroom:

Peer Review Sounding Board


We have been asked to take part in the 2009 NetGenEd Project which links 18 different schools in 6 different countries. These students are creating videos that help explain the main topics discussed in the Horizon Report and the book Grown Up Digital.

We have been asked to review and comment on their work. Your comments will be read both by these students and by some serious experts who are evaluating the project. Your main audience is the students. You should remember in your writing that they are working very hard and also that only some of them are from English-speaking countries.

2009 Project Outline

Peer Review



Our task is to review and comment on their wiki work and video work.
Our comments will be read both by these students and by some serious experts who are evaluating the project.
The main audience for our comments are the high school students.
We need to remember in our writing that they are working very hard to meet the judging criteria for the NetGenEd project.


Organization of Topics for Peer Review


There are 6 topics. Each team has 8 sub-groups. We will review one of the 6 topics and all of the 8 sub-groups within that topic.
We will review a topic as a class to introduce and acquaint ourselves with the Review process.
Next, we will split into groups of 3 to evaluate 4 of the group projects:

Projects in Progress
Student Groups Providing Feedback
Your Feedback Pages

A.1 Choice and Mobiles

Alex, Matt, Hollie
Choice

A.2 Customization and Mobiles

Phu, Josh, Han Kyu
Customization

A.3 Transparency and Mobiles

Natalie, Sarah, Nicole
Transparency

A.4 Integrity and Mobiles

Olivia, Gwen, Alex
Integrity

A.5 Collaboration and Mobiles

Isabel, Helen, Kayo
Collaboration

A.6 Fun and Mobiles

Malina, Kayla, Sophie
Fun

A.7 Speed and Mobiles

Sarah, Yuri, Mana
Speed

A.8 Innovation and Mobiles

Matt, Abhi, Sarah
Innovation




Graphic Organizer


We will use the 321 Graphic Organizer for our review comments.
  • 3 good things about the wiki/video topic
  • 2 improvements for the wiki/video topic
  • 1 piece of new knowledge that your group has acquired due to these high school students participating in the Flatclassroom Project